| 2,626 | 42 | 70 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
推动公民参与共建共治共享，是降低公共服务成本、提高社会治理效能的重要方面，因此，探究公民共同生产行为的影响因素对坚持和完善共建共治共享的社会治理制度具有基础性的意义。本文构建了一个公民环境共同生产行为的多层分析框架，基于CGSS2010和CGSS2013数据，采用HLM多层线性回归模型检验了地区层面因素和个体层面因素对公民共同生产行为的影响。研究发现，公民共同生产行为同时受益于地区和个体两个层面的贡献：在地区层面，地方政府的环境宣传教育对公民的环境共同生产行为产生了直接的正向影响；在个体层面，个体的共同生产能力与共同生产心理都正向作用于共同生产行为，相较于能力因素，个体的心理因素对共同生产行为的影响更强。研究结果在理论上扩充了共同生产激励因素的解释框架，在实践上有助于政府部门有针对性地制定相关激励政策，推进共建共治共享的治理创新。
Abstract：Promoting citizens' participation in co-construction, co-governance and sharing is considered as an important aspect of reducing the cost of public services and improving the efficiency of social governance. Therefore, exploring the factors influencing citizens' co-production behavior is fundamental to improve the social governance system of co-construction, co-governance and sharing. Based on CGSS2010 and CGSS2013 data, this paper uses a hierarchical linear modeling(HLM) to examine the influence of organizational factors and individual factors on coproduction behavior of citizens. The results show that the strategies to promote coproduction behavior benefit from both individual and organizational contributions. At the organizational level, the environmental publicity and education from government has a direct positive impact on coproduction behavior of citizens. At the individual level, individual capacity and motivation both affect coproduction behavior. Especially, the impact of individual motivation to behavior is more stronger than capacity does. This research addresses a sizeable gap in coproduction research and deepen our understanding of citizens' behavior on environmental coproduction. It also provides a basis through to explore how to motivate citizens' participation in co-construction, co-governance and sharing in practice.
1.Osborne,S.P.Radnor,Z.Strokosch,K.，“Co-production and the co-creation of value in public services:Asuitable case for treatment?”.Public Management Review,Vol.18,No.5-6,2016,pp.639~653.
2.Nabatchi,T.Sancino,A.Sicilia,M.，“Varieties of participation in public services:The who,when,and what of coproduction”.Public Administration Review,Vol.77,No.5,2017,pp.766~776.
3.Brudney,J.L.，“Local coproduction of services and the analysis of municipal productivity”.Urban Affairs Quarterly,Vol.19,No.4,1984,pp.465~484.
4.Bovaird,T.Loeffler,E.，“From engagement to coproduction:The contribution of users and communities to outcomes and public value”.Voluntas,Vol.23,No.4,2012,pp.1119~1138.
5.唐国平、李龙会、吴德军：《环境管制、行业属性与企业环保投资》，《会计研究》2013年第6期。
6.王斌：《环境污染治理与规制博弈研究》，首都经济贸易大学2013年版。
7。金刚、沈坤荣：《以邻为壑还是以邻为伴?---环境规制执行互动与城市生产率增长》，《管理世界》2018年第12期。
8.Ianniello,M.Silvia,I.Paolo,F.et al.，“Obstacles and solutions on the ladder of citizen participation:A systematic review”.Public Management Review,Vol.21,No.1,2019,pp.21~46.
9.Alford,J.Yates,S.，“Co-production of public services in Australia:The roles of government organisations and co-producers”.Australian Journal of Public Administration,Vol.75,No.2,2016,pp.159~175.
10.Bovaird,T.Van Ryzin,G.G.Loeffler,E.et al.，“Activating citizens to participate in collective co-production of public services”.Journal of Social Policy,Vol.44,No.1,2015,pp.1~23.
11.Alford,J.，“Why do public-sector clients coproduce?Toward a contingency theory”,Administration&Society,Vol.34,No.1,2002,pp.32~56.
12.Alford,J.,Engaging Public Sector Clients:From Service-Delivery to Co-Production.London:Palgrave Macmillan,2009.
13.Alonso,J.M.Andrews,R.Clifton,J.et al.，“Factors influencing citizens’co-production of environmental outcomes:A multi-level analysis”.Public Management Review,Vol.21,No.11,2019,pp.1620~1645.
14.Bovaird,T.Stoker,G.Jones,T.et al.，“Activating collective co-production of public services:Influencing citizens to participate in complex governance mechanisms in the UK”.International Review of Administrative Sciences,Vol.82,No.1,2016,pp.47~68.
15.Voorberg,W.H.Bekkers,V.J.J.M.Tummers,L.G.，“A systematic review of co-creation and co-production:Embarking on the social innovation journey”.Public Management Review,Vol.17,No.9,2015,pp.1333~1357.
16.Manes-Rossi,F.Brusca,I.Orelli,R.L.et al.，“Features and drivers of citizen participation:Insights from participatory budgeting in three European cities”.Public Management Review,2021,pp.1~23.
17.Whitaker G.P.，“Coproduction:Citizen participation in service delivery”.Public Administration Review,Vol.40,No.3,1980,pp.240~246.
18.Percy,S.L.，“Citizen participation in the coproduction of urban services”.Urban Affairs Review,Vol.19,No.4,1984,pp.431~446.
19.Sundeen,R.A.，“Explaining participation in coproduction:A study of volunteers”.Social Science Quarterly,Vol.69,No.3,1988,pp.547~568.
20.Marschall,M.J.，“Citizen participation and the neighborhood context:A new look at the coproduction of local public goods”.Political Research Quarterly,Vol.57,No.2,2004,pp.231~244.
21.Hadler,M.Haller,M.，“Global activism and nationally driven recycling:The influence of world society and national contexts on public and private environmental behavior”.International Sociology,Vol.26,No.3,2011,pp.315~345.
22.施生旭、甘彩云：《环保工作满意度、环境知识与公众环保行为---基于CGSS2013数据分析》，《软科学》2017年第11期。
23.王琰：《我国居民绿色消费影响因素的多层次分析：基于CGSS2010的实证研究》，《南京工业大学学报》（社会科学版）2015年第2期。
24.曾昭鹏：《环境素养的理论与测评研究》，南京师范大学2004年版。
25.Pateman,C.，“Participatory Democracy Revisited”.Perspectives on Politics,Vol.10,No.1,2012,pp.7~19.
26.Van Eijk,C.Steen,T.，“Why engage in co-production of public services?Mixing theory and empirical evidence”.International Review of Administrative Sciences,Vol.82,No.1,2016,pp.28~46.
27.郑思齐、万广华、孙伟增等：《公众诉求与城市环境治理》，《管理世界》2013年第6期。
28.Bandura,A.,Self-Efficacy:The Exercise of Control.New York:Freeman,1997.
29.Parrado,S.Van Ryzin,G.G.Bovaird,T.et al.，“Correlates of co-production:Evidence from a five-nation survey of citizens”.International Public Management Journal,Vol.16,No.1,2013,pp.85~112.
30.Loeffler,E.,Bovaird,T.,Parrado,S.,&Van Ryzin,G.，“If you want to go fast,walk alone:If you want to go far,walk together”:Citizens and the co-production of public services.Report to the EU Presidency.Paris:Ministry of Finance,Budget and Public Services,2008.
31.Loeffler,E.，“Commentary:Coproduction of public outcomes:where do citizens fit in?”.Public Administration Review,Vol.76,No.3,2016,pp.436~437.
32.Bovaird,T.Van Ryzin,G.G.Loeffler,E.et al.，“Activating citizens to participate in collective co-production of public services”.Journal of Social Policy,Vol.44,No.1,2016,pp.1~23.
33.Andfossen,N.B.，“Co-production between longterm care units and voluntary organizations in Norwegian municipalities:A theoretical discussion and empirical analysis”.Primary Health Care Research&Development,Vol.21,No.e33,2020,pp.1~8.
34.Voorberg,W.H.Bekkers V.J.J.M.Tummers,L.G.，“A systematic review of co-creation and co-production:Embarking on the social innovation journey”.Public Management Review,Vol.17,No.9,2015,pp.1333~1357.
35.高孟菲、郑晶：《经济发展、政府投入与公众环境友好行为---基于CGSS 2013数据的实证分析》，《福建农林大学学报》（哲学社会科学版）2019年第6期。
36.徐顺青、逯元堂、陈鹏等：《2012-2016年中央财政生态环境保护支出分析》，《中国环境管理》2018年第6期。
37.Raudenbush S.W.Bryk A.S.,Hierarchical Linear Models:Applications and Data Analysis Methods(2nd ed).Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage,2002.
38.Voorberg,W.Jilke,S.L.Tummers,L.et al.，“Financial rewards do not stimulate coproduction:Evidence from two experiments”.Public Administration Review,Vol.78,No.6,2018,pp.864~73.
39.Loeffler,E.,Co-Production of Public Services and Outcomes,Switzerland:Palgrave Macmillan,2021.
40.Guagnano,G.A.Stern,P.C.Dietz,T.，“Influences on attitude-behavior relationships”.Environment&Behavior,Vol.27,1995,pp.699~718.
41.Sicilia,M.Guarini,E.Sancino,A.et al.，“Public services management and co-production in multi-level governance settings”,International Review of Administrative Sciences,Vol.82,No.1,2016,pp.8~27.
42.Thomas,J.C.，“Citizen,customer,partner:rethinking the place of the public in public management”,Public Administration Review,Vol.73,No.6,2013,pp.786~796.
43.Meijer,A.J.Torenvlied,R.，“Social media and the new organization of government communications:an empirical analysis of twitter usage by the Dutch police”,American Review of Public Administration,Vol.46,No.2,2014,pp.143~161.
44.Lember,V.Brandsen,T.T?nurist,P.，“The potential impacts of digital technologies on co-production and co-creation”,Public Management Review,Vol.21,No.11,2019,pp.1665~1686.
①第一次全国污染源普查公报（2010）显示，生活污染源约占污染源总数的1/4。第二次全国污染源普查公报（2020）显示，生活污染源约占污染源总数的1/5。从水污染排放情况来看，生活源污染排放远远高于工业源污染排放量。
②ICC(1）的值由τ00÷（σ2+τ00）计计算得到。根据Randenbush和Bryk对ICC(1）数值的划分：ICC(1)<0.059为低度组内相关；0.059<0.138为中度组内相关；ICC(1)>0.138为高度组内相关。
基本信息:
DOI：10.14167/j.zjss.2022.05.010
中图分类号:X32;D630
引用信息:
[1]吴结兵,钱倩严慧.公民共同生产行为的影响因素研究——基于环境治理的多层次分析[J].浙江社会科学,2022,No.309(05):76-85+157-158.DOI:10.14167/j.zjss.2022.05.010.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金重大项目“加快推进市域社会治理现代化研究”（20ZDA082）; 国家自然科学基金面上项目“我国社会组织‘国家-市场’二元性与组织能力建设研究”（71774139）; 浙江省哲学社会科学规划“高质量发展建设共同富裕示范区”重大招标课题“共同富裕现代化基本单元建设研究”
2022-05-10
2022-05-10