| 411 | 7 | 54 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
精神分裂症是一种常见的病因未明的精神障碍,表现出稳定的社会认知障碍。现象学精神病理学使用自我与他人同一性和他异性的紊乱来描绘精神分裂症上述障碍。神经现象学的介入有助于澄清交互主体性层面上精神分裂症患者的自我干扰与社会缺陷之间的关系。精神分裂症患者在多感觉整合上存在脑功能异常,主要表现为腹前运动皮层的多感觉表征受损。这种异常会影响连贯、原真的身体体验,从而产生自我干扰。扣带回皮层和腹侧前运动皮层之间的异常功能连接导致精神分裂症患者内在自我与外在自我之间的交互异常,破坏了自我与他人关系中的不对称性,加剧了同一性与他异性的紊乱,表现出超反思、自我感减弱与激进的他异性。
Abstract：Schizophrenia is a common mental disorder with unknown etiology. Its symptoms are grouped as positive, negative, and cognitive, while its prominent social cognition deficits exist and persist. Inspired by classical phenomenology, phenomenological psychopathology uses the disorder of self-other identity and alterity to describe interpersonal interaction deficits in schizophrenia. It helps to clarify the relationship between self and others in schizophrenia patients at the level of intersubjectivity, and meanwhile provide the brain and neural basis for the in-depth study of the relationship between self-disturbances and social deficits.Current neurophenomenological evidence suggests that patients with schizophrenia have abnormal brain function in multisensory integration, mainly manifested by impaired multisensory representation in the ventral premotor cortex. This anomaly can interfere with the coherent, primordial physical experience, causing selfdisturbance. Furthermore, the abnormal functional connections between the cingulate cortex and the ventral premotor cortex lead to abnormal interactions between the inner and outer selves, breaking the asymmetry between the self and others, and exacerbating the disorder of identity and alterity. In the end, patients with schizophrenia show hyper-reflexivity, diminished self-affection and radical alterity.
(1)Insel,T.R.“Rethinking schizophrenia”,Nature,2010,468(7321),187~193.
(2)David L.P.,Lawrence J.S.and David L.R.“Social cognition in schizophrenia:an overview”,Schizophrenia Bulletin,2008,34(3),408~411.
(3)Green,M.F.,Horan,W.P.and Lee,J.“Social cognition in schizophrenia”,Nature Reviews Neuroscience,2015,16(10),620~631.
(4)Bleuler,M.and Bleuler,R.“Dementia praecox oder die Gruppe der Schizophrenien:Eugen Bleuler”,The British Journal of Psychiatry,1986,149(5),661~662.
(5)Fisher,M.,Mc Coy,K.,Poole,J.H.and Vinogradov,S.“Self and other in schizophrenia:A cognitive neuroscience perspective”,American Journal of Psychiatry,2008,165,1465~1472.
(6)Parnas,J.,Bovet,P.and Zahavi,D.“Schizophrenic autism:Clinical phenomenology and pathogenetic implications”,World Psychiatry,2002,1,131~136.
(7)Gallese,V.“Being like me:Self-other identity,mirror neurons,and empathy”,In:Hurley,S.and Chater,N.(Eds.).Perspectives on imitation:From cognitive neuroscience to social science,Cambridge,MA:MIT Press,2005,101~118.
(8)Stern,D.N.The interpersonal world of the infant,New York:Routledge,2018.
(9)Meltzoff,A.N.and Blooks,R.“Like me as a building block for understanding other mind:bodily acts,attention,and intension”,In:B.F.Malle,L.J.Moses,and D.A.Baldwin(Eds.).Intentions and intentionality:Foundations of social cognition,Cambridge,MA:The MIT Press,2001,171~191.
(10)(11)Husserl,E.The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology:An Introduction to Phenomenological Philosophy(D.Carr Trans.),Evanston,IL:Northwestern University Press,1970.
(12)Zahavi D.Self-Awareness and Alterity:A Phenomenological Investigation,Evanston:Northwestern University Press,1999.
(13)Husserl E.Erste Philosophie(1923/24),Zweiter Teil.Husserliana VIII.Ed.R.Boehm,The Hague:Nijhoff,1959.
(14)(19)(56)(58)S?ren,O.and Mads,G.H.“Alterity”.In:G.Stanghellini,M.Broome,A.Raballo,A.V.Fernandez,P.Fusar-Poli,and R.Rosfort(Eds.).The Oxford Handbook of Phenomenological Psychopathology,2018,1~10.
(15)(16)(18)Husserl,E.Cartesian Meditations:An Introduction to Phenomenology(Cairns D.trans.),Dordrecht:Kluwer Academic Publishers,1995,109~112.参见胡塞尔：《笛卡尔式的沉思》，张廷国译，中国城市出版社2002年版，第153、155、131~133页。
(17)Merleau-Ponty,M.Phenomenology of Perception(Landes D.trans.),London:Routledge,2012,190~191.参见梅洛-庞蒂：《知觉现象学》，姜志辉译，商务印书馆2001年版，第454页。
(20)V.Gallese.“Embodied Simulation:From Neurons to Phenomenal Experience”,Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences,2005,4(1),23~48.
(21)(38)Stein,E.On the Problem of Empathy(Stein,W.Trans.),Washington,DC:ICS Publications,1989.参见施泰因：《论移情问题》，张浩军译，华东师范大学出版社2014年版，第34、40页。
(22)Husserl,E.Cartesianische Meditationen und Pariser Vortr覿ge,Husserliana I.Den Haag:M.Nijhoff,1973,139.
(23)Gallese,V.“The roots of empathy:The shared manifold hypothesis and the neural basis of intersubjectivity”,Psychopathology,2003,36,171~180.
(24)(27)Gallese V.“The‘shared manifold’hypothesis:From mirror neurons to empathy”,Journal of Consciousness Studies,2001,8(5~7),33~50.
(25)Gallese,V.,Keysers,C.and Rizzolatti,G.“A unifying view of the basis of social cognition”,Trends in Cognitive Science,2004,8,396~403.
(26)Bastiaansen,J.A.,Thioux,M.and Keysers,C.“Evidence for mirror systems in emotions”,Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B,Biological Sciences,2009,364,2391~2404.
(28)Blakemore,S.J.,Smith,J.,Steel,R.,Johnstone,C.E.and Frith,C.D.“The perception of self-produced sensory stimuli in patients with auditory hallucinations and passivity experiences:Evidence for a breakdown in self-monitoring”,Psychological Medicine,2000,30,1131~1139.
(29)Keysers,C.,Kaas,J.H.and Gazzola,V.“Somatosensation in social perception”,Nature Reviews Neuroscience,2010,11,417~428.
(30)(31)Peter,J.U.and Aaron L.M.“Perceptual Anomalies in Schizophrenia:Integrating Phenomenology and Cognitive Neuroscience”,Schizophrenia Bulletin,2007,33(1),142~156.
(32)Mc Ghie.A.and Chapman,J.“Disorders of attention and perception in early schizophrenia”,British Journal of Medical Psychology,1961,34,103~115.
(33)(35)Lisa,E.W.,Gregory,A.L.,David,L.B.and Vilayanur,S.R.“Reduced multisensory integration in patients with schizophrenia on a target detection task”,Neuropsychologia,2010,48(10),3128~3136.
(34)de Gelde,B.,Vroomen,J.,de Jong,S.J.,Masthoff,E.D.,Trompenaars,F.J.and Hodiamont,P.“Multisensory integration of emotional faces and voices in schizophrenics”,Schizophrenia Research,2005,72(2~3),195~203.
(36)Stekelenburg,J.J.,Maes,J.P.,Van Gool,A.R.,Sitskoorn,M.and Vroomen,J.“Deficient multisensory integration in schizophrenia:An event-related potential study”,Schizophrenia Research,2013,147,253~261.
(37)Nelson,B.,Whitford,T.J.,Lavoie,S.and Sass,L.A.“What are the neurocognitive correlates of basic self-disturbance in schizophrenia?Integrating phenomenology and neurocognition”,Schizophrenia Research,2014,152,12~19.
(39)(42)Ebisch,S.J.and Gallese.V.“A Neuroscientific Perspective on the Nature of Altered Self-Other Relationships in Schizophrenia”,Journal of Consciousness Studies,2015,22(1~2),220~240.
(40)Daprati,E.,Franck,N.,Georgieff,N.,Proust,J.,Pacherie,E.,Dalery,J.and Jeannerod,M.“Looking for the agent:An investigation into consciousness of action and selfconsciousness in schizophrenic patients”,Cognition,1997,65,71~86.
(41)Morgan,H.L.,Turner,D.C.,Corlett,P.R.,Absalom,A.R.,Adapa,R.,Arana,F.S.,Pigott,J.,Gardner,J.,Everitt,J.,Haggard,P.and Fletcher,P.C.“Exploring the impact of ketamine on the experience of illusory body ownership”,Biological Psychiatry,2011,69,35~41.
(43)(44)(46)Ebisch,S.J.,Salone,A.,Ferri,F.,De Berardis,D.,Romani,G.L.,Ferro,F.M.and Gallese,V.“Out of touch with reality?Social perception in first-episode schizophrenia”,Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience,2013a,8,394~403.
(45)Farrer,C.,Franck,N.and Frith,C.D.“Neural correlates of action attribution in schizophrenia”,Psychiatry Research,2004,131,31~44.
(47)Skudlarski,P.,Jagannathan,K.,Anderson,K.,Stevens,M.C.,Calhoun,V.D.,Skudlarska,B.A.and Pearlson,G.“Brain connectivity is not only lower but different in schizophrenia:A combined anatomical and functional approach”,Biological Psychiatry,2010,68,61~69.
(48)Northoff,G.and Bermpohl,F.“Cortical midline structures and the self”,Trends in Cognitive Science,2004,8,102~107.
(49)(51)Ebisch,S.J.,Mantini,D.,Northoff,G.,Salone,A.,De Berardis,D.,Ferri,F.,Ferro,F.M.,Di Giannantonio,M.,Romani,G.L.and Gallese,V.“Altered brain long-range functional interactions underlying the link between aberrant self-experience and self-other relationship in first-episode schizophrenia”,Schizophrenia Bulletin,2014,40(5),1072~1082.
(50)Fox,M.D.,Zhang,D.,Snyder,A.Z.and Raichle,M.E.“The global signal and observed anticorrelated resting state brain networks”,Journal of Neurophysiology,2009,101,3270~3283.
(52)Nelson,B.,Fornito,A.,Harrison B.J.,Yücel,M.,Sass,L.A.,Yung,A.R.,Thompson,A.,Wood,S.J.,Pantelis,C.and Mc Gorry P.D.“A disturbed sense of self in the psychosis prodrome:Linking phenomenology and neurobiology”,Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews,2009,33(6),807~817.
(53)Parnas,J.and Jansson L.B.“Self-disorders:Clinical and conceptual implications for the diagnostic concept of schizophrenia”,Psychopathology,2015,48(5),332~338.
(54)Sass,L.A.and Parnas,J.“Schizophrenia,consciousness,and the self”,Schizophrenia Bulletin,2003,29(3),427~444.
(55)Henriksen,M.G.,Skodlar,B.,Sass,L.A.and Parnas,J.“Autism and perplexity:A qualitative and theoretical study of basic subjective experiences in schizophrenia”,Psychopathology,2010,43,357~368.
(57)Schneider K.Klinische Psychopathologie,Stuttgart:Georg Thieme Verlag,1950.
基本信息:
DOI：10.14167/j.zjss.2020.04.011
中图分类号:R749.3
引用信息:
[1]徐慧艳,陈巍.同一性与他异性的紊乱——精神分裂症社会感知障碍的神经现象学分析[J].浙江社会科学,2020,No.284(04):90-98+158.DOI:10.14167/j.zjss.2020.04.011.
基金信息:
教育部人文社科规划青年基金项目“幼儿阅读理解的具身认知基础及其教育应用研究”(编号：17YJC880111);; 国家社会科学基金一般项目“现象学与精神病理学的相互澄明关系研究”(编号：17BZX084)的阶段性成果
2020-04-13
2020-04-13