| 10,060 | 171 | 136 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
本文探讨了作为一种新的质性研究方法的自我民族志。自我民族志是一种将个人与文化相联系的自传式个人叙事,这种个人叙事对个人亲身经历进行了描述并对个人的文化经历进行了反思性说明。近年来,自我民族志已成为研究个人与文化问题的首选工具。本文首先界定了自我民族志的内涵,并在此基础上对自我民族志的由来、后现代主义的思想渊源、四种表达方式以及主要的学术争论进行了探讨。最后,本文对自我民族志的优点和不足进行了评价,并对其社会应用价值进行分析。
Abstract：This paper examined autoethnography as a new qualitative research method.Auto-ethnography is a form of autobiographical personal narrative that links a person to his/her culture.The personal narrative describes the writer's experience of life and explains reflectively the experiences of culture.In recent years,autoethnography has become a major instrument of studying the issues regarding the individual and culture.The paper began with a definition of autoethnography,followed by a discussion of the origins of auto-ethnography,its postmodernism impact,its four expression styles,and some debates about it.Finally,the paper identified pros and cons of autoethnography and proposed its implications for the social science research in China.
1.[美]艾利丝和博克纳:《作为主体的研究者:自我的民族志、个体叙事、自反性》,载[美]邓津和林肯:《定性研究(第3卷):经验资料收集与分析的方法》,风笑天等译,重庆大学出版社2007年版,第777～822页。
2.[美]劳伦斯.纽曼:《社会研究方法:定性和定量的取向(第五版)》,郝大海译,中国人民大学出版社2007年版,第114～115页。
3.Adler,P.A.,&Adler,P.(1987).Membership roles in field research.Newbury Park,CA:Sage.
4.Alvesson,M.,&Skoldberg,K.(2000).Reflexive Methodologies:Interpretation and Research.London,Sage.
5.Atkinson,P.(1997).Narrative turn in a blind al-ley-Qualitative Health Research,7:325-344.
6.Bochner,A.P.(2001).Narrative's virtues.Quali-tative Inquiry,7(2),131-157.
7.Bochner,A.P.&Ellis,C.S.(2006).Communi-cation as Autoethnography.In G.J.Sheperd,J.St.John,&T.Striphas(Eds.).Communication as…:Perspectives on Theory.Thousand Oakes,CA:Sage,pp.110-122.
8.Boehner,A.P.,Ellis,C.,&Tillmann-Healy,L.(1997).Relationships as stories,in S.Duck(ed.),Handbook ofpersonal relationships:Theory,research and in-terventions(2nd ed.).New York:John Wiley,pp.307-324.
9.Boehner,A.P.,Ellis,C.,&Tillmann-Healy,L.(1998).Mucking around looking for truth.In B.M.Montgomery&L.A.Baxter(Eds.).Dialectical approach to studying personal relationships.Mahwah,NJ:Lawrence Erl-baum,pp.41-62.
10.Bruce,T.(2000)Never let the bastards see you cry,Sociology ofSport Journal,17,69-74.
11.Chamberlayne,E,Bomat,J.,&Wengraf,T.(2000).The turn to biographical methods in social science.London:Routledge.
12.Chang,Heewon(2008).Autoethnography as meth-od.Walnut Creek,CA:Left Coast Press.
13.Charmaz,K.,&Mitchell,R.(1997).The myth of silent authorship:Self,substance,and style in ethnogra-phic writing.In R.Hertz,(Ed.),Reflexivity and voice.London:Sage,pp.193-215.
14.Coffey,P.(1999).The ethnographic self.London:Sage.
15.Deck,A.(1990).Autoethrography:Zora Neale Hurston,Noni Jahavu,and cross-disciplinary discourse.Black American Literature Forum,24:237-256.
16.Denzin,N.K.,&Lincoln,Y.S.(1994).Intro-duction:Entering the field of qualitative research.In N.K.Denzin&Y.S.Lincoln(Eds.),Handbook ofqualitative re-search(pp.1-17).Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
17.DeVault,M.(1997).Personal writing in social re-search.In R.Hertz(Ed.),Reflexivity and voice(pp.216-228).London:Sage.
18.Ellis,C.(2000).Creating criteria:An ethnogra-phic short story.Qualitative Inquiry,6(2),273-277.
19.Ellis,C.(2004).The ethnographic I:A methodo-logical novel about autoethnography.USA,Rowan and Little-field.
20.Ellis,C.(2008).Autoethnography.In L.M.Giv-en(ed.)The sage encyclopedia ofqualitative research meth-ods.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
21.Ellis,C.,&Bochner,A.(2000).Auto-ethnog-raphy,personal narrative,reflexivity:Researcher as subject.In N.K.Denzin&Y.S.Lincoln(Eds.),Handbook of qualitative research(2nd ed.,pp.733-768).Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
22.Eisner,E.W.(1997).The newfrontier in qualita-tive research methodology.Qualitative Inquiry,3,259-273.
23.Geertz,C.(1997).The interpretation ofcultures:Selected essays.New York:Basic Books.
24.Hayano,D.M.(1979).Auto-ethnography:Par-adigms,problems,and prospects.Human Organization,38:113-120.
25.Holt,N.L.(2003).Representation,Legitima-tion,and Autoethnography:An Auto-ethnographic Writing Story,International Journal ofQualitative Methods,2:(1):1-22.
26.Jackson,M.(1989).Paths toward a clearing:Radical empiricism and ethnographic inquiry.Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
27.Jones,S.H.(2005).Mothering loss:Telling per-formativity.Text and Performance Quarterly.25(2):113-135.
28.Jules-Rosette,B.(1975).African apostle.Itha-ca,NY:Cornell University Press.
29.Lapadat,J.C.(2009).Writing our way into shared understanding:Collaborative autobiographical writing in the qualitative methods class.Qualitative Inquiry,15:955-979.
30.McIlveen,P.(2008).Autoethnography as a meth-od for reflexive research and practice in vocational psychol-ogy.Australian Journal ofCareer Development,17(2):13-20.
31.Mehan,H.&Wood,H.(1975).The realityofeth-nomethodology.New York:John Wiley.
32.Neumannn,M.(1996).Collecting ourselves at the end of the century.In C.Ellis&A.P.Bochner(eds.),Composing ethnography:Alternative forms ofqualitative writ-ing.Walnut Creek,CA:AltaMira.
33.Patton,M.Q.(1999).Grand Canyon celebration:A father-son journey ofdiscovery.Amherst,NY:Prome-theus.
34.Patton,M.Q.(2002).Qualitative research and e-valuation methods.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
35.Patton,M.Q.(2004).Autoethnography.In L.B.Michael(ed.)The sage encyclopedia ofsocial science research methods.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
36.Ponterotto,J.G.(2005).Qualitative research in counseling psychology:A primer on research paradigms and philosophy of science.Journal ofCounseling Psychology,52(2),126-136.
37.Reed-Danahay,D.(1997).Auto-ethnography:Rewriting the selfand the social.Oxford,UK:Berg.
38.Richardson,L.(1995).Writing-stories:Co-au-thoring'The sea monster,'a writing story.Qualitative In-quiry,1:189-203.
39.Richardson,L.(1998).The politics of location:Where am I now-Qualitative Inquiry,4(1),41-48.
40.Richardson,L.(2000).Writing:A method of in-quiry.In N.K.Denzin&Y.S.Lincoln(Eds.),Handbook ofqualitative research(2nd ed.).Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.pp.923-948.
41.Rosenau,P.M.(1992).Postmodernism and the social sciences.Princeton,NJ:Princeton University Press.
42.Shotter,J.(1987).The social construction of an"us":Problem of accountability and narratology.In R.Bur-nett,P.McGee,&D.Clarke(eds.),Accounting for rela-tionships:Eexplanation,representation,and knowledge,Lon-don:Methuen,pp225-247.
43.Sparkes,A.C.(2002).Autoethnography:Self-indulgence or something more-In A.Bochner&C.Ellis(Eds.),Ethnographicallyspeaking:Autoethnography,litera-ture,and aesthetics.New York:AltaMira.
44.Van Manen,J.(1988).Tales ofthe field:On writ-ing ethnography.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
45.Wilson,T.D.,&Dunn,E.W.(2004).Self-knowledge:Its limits,value and potential for improvement.Annual ReviewofPsychology,55:493-518.
46.Young,R.A.,&Collin,A.(2004).Introduc-tion:Constructivism and social constructionism in the career field.Journal ofVocational Behavior,64:373-388.
基本信息:
DOI：10.14167/j.zjss.2011.04.015
中图分类号:C95
引用信息:
[1]蒋逸民.自我民族志:质性研究方法的新探索[J].浙江社会科学,2011,No.176(04):11-18+155.DOI:10.14167/j.zjss.2011.04.015.
2011-04-15
2011-04-15