| 706 | 8 | 44 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
贸易保护等因素所产生的市场分割一直是人们关注的话题,但是对其全面而准确的度量却长期困扰着学术界。McCallum(1995)应用极其简洁的引力方程定量估计了美国-加拿大边界导致的两国间市场分割程度,出乎意料的结果引起了学术界的广泛兴趣。引力方程也因此被许多研究者用于随后的经验研究、并随着经济全球化被推到了国际贸易研究领域的前台。随着新的贸易特征和贸易理论的出现,对边界效应的估计在理论、方法、结论和解释上都发生了巨大变化。本文根据引力方程发展过程、逻辑关联和理论基础对相关文献作了全面回顾和梳理,并对重要的理论、方法和实证结果进行比较。特别地,本文还对采用该方法研究我国国内市场分割现状的文献进行了回顾,并对进一步的研究提出了建议。
Abstract：Market segregation resulting from protectionism or other factors has been a prime interest by academic researchers.But proper and accurate measurement of segregation has been particularly troublesome.Employing a concise gravity equation with border effects,McCallum(1995)was able to quantify the extent of market segregation between US and Canada.The results surprised the academic circle and aroused great interest in this topic.The gravity equation soon emerged on the frontier of academic research,and was used extensively in subsequent empirical studies.With new evidence unrevealed and new theories developed over time,studies on border effects have changed dramatically in theoretical foundations,methodology,results,and interpretations.This article gives a thorough review over recent literature on border effects according to their theoretical relations and the course of development.We make a systematic comparison between different theories,methods,and results.Specifically,we also include a review of recent studies on China's market segregation,for which we have suggested a few ways for future improvement.
1.黄赜琳、王敬云:《地方保护与市场分割:来自中国的经验数据》,《中国工业经济》2006年第2期。
2.黄赜琳、王敬云:《基于产业结构区际贸易壁垒的实证分析》,《财经研究》2007年第3期。
3.赵永亮、徐勇:《国内贸易与区际边界效应:保护与偏好》,《管理世界》2007年第9期。
4.赵永亮、徐勇、苏桂富:《区际壁垒与贸易的边界效应》,《世界经济》2008年第2期。
5.朱希伟、金祥荣、罗德明:《国内市场分割与中国的出口贸易扩张》,《经济研究》2005年第12期。
6.Anderson,J.E.(1979),“A theoretical foundation for the gravity equation”,The American Economic Review,69(1),106-116.
7.Anderson,J.E.,and E.van Wincoop(2003),“Gravity with gravitas:a solution to the border puzzle”,The American Economic Review,93(1),170-192.
8.Anderson,J.E.,and E.van Wincoop(2004),“Trade costs”,The Journal ofEconomic Literature,42(3),691-751.
9.Bai,C.-E.,Y.Du,Z.Tao,and S.Y.Tong(2004),“Local protectionism and regional specialization:evidence from China’s industries”,Journal ofInternational Economics,63(2),397-417.
10.Baier,S.L.,and J.H.Bergstrand(2002),“On the endogeneity of international trade flows and free trade a-greements”,working paper,University of Notre Dame.
11.Baier,S.L.,and J.H.Bergstrand(2004),“E-conomic determinants of free trade agreements”,Journal of International Economics,64(1),29-63.
12.Chen,N.A.(2004),“Intra-national versus in-ternational trade in the European Union:Why do national borders matter-”,Journal of International Economics,63(1),93-118.
13.Combes,P.-P.,M.Lafourcade,and T.Mayer(2003),“Can business and social networks explain the bor-der effect puzzle-”,CEPII working papers,No.2003-02.
14.Eaton,J.,and S.Kortum(2002),“Technology,geography,and trade”,Econometrica,70(5),1741-1779.
15.Eaton,J.,S.Kortum,and F.Kramarz(2004),“Dissecting trade:firms,industries,and export destina-tions”,The American Economic Review,94(2),150-154.
16.Evans,C.L.(2003),“The economic significance of national border effects”,The American Economic Review,93(4),1291-1312.
17.Evans,C.L.(2006),“Border effects and the a-vailability of domestic products abroad”,The Canadian Jour-nal ofEconomics,39(1),211-246.
18.Feenstra,R.C.(2002),“Border effects and the gravity equation:consistent methods for estimation”,Scottish Journal ofPolitical Economy,49(5),491-506.
19.Feenstra,R.C.,J.R.Markusen,and A.K.Rose(2001),“Using the gravity equation to differentiate a-mong alternative theories of trade”,The Canadian Journal of Economics,34(2),430-447.
20.Head,K.,and T.Mayer(2000),“Non-Europe:the magnitude and causes of market fragmentation in the EU”,Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv,136(2),284-314.
21.Head,K.,and T.Mayer(2002),“Illusory border effects:distance mismeasurement inflates estimates of home bias in trade”,CEPII working papers,No.2002-01.
22.Helliwell,J.F.(1996),“Do national borders mat-ter for Quebec’s trade-”,The Canadian Journal ofEconom-ics,29(3),507-522.
23.Helliwell,J.F.(1997),“National borders,trade and migration”,Pacific Economic Review,2(3),165-185.
24.Helliwell,J.F.(2002),“Measuring the width of national borders”,Review of International Economics,10(3),517-524.
25.Helliwell,J.F.,and G.Verdier(2001),“Meas-uring internal trade distances:a new method applied to esti-mate provincial border effects in Canada”,The Canadian Journal ofEconomics,34(4),1024-1041.
26.Helpman,E.,and P.R.Krugman(1985),Mar-ket structure and foreign trade.The MITPress,U.S.A.
27.Helpman,E.,M.Melitz,and Y.Rubinstein(2008),“Estimating trade flows:trading partners and trading volumes”,The Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,123(2),441-487.
28.Hillberry,R.(2001),“Aggregation bias,composi-tional change,and the border effect”,U.S.International Trade Commission working papers,No.2001-04-B.
29.Hillberry,R.,and D.Hummels(2002),“Explai-ning home bias in consumption:the role of intermediate input trade”,NBER working papers,No.9020.
30.Hillberry,R.,and D.Hummels(2003),“Intrana-tional home bias:some explanations”,The Review ofEco-nomics and Statistics,85(4),1089-1092.
31.Hillberry,R.,and D.Hummels(2008),“Trade responses to geographic frictions:a decomposition using micro-data”,European Economic Review,52(3),527-550.
32.Linneman,H.(1966),An econometric study ofin-ternational trade flows.North-Holland Pub.Co.,The Netherlands.
33.McCallum,J.(1995),“National borders matter:Canada-U.S.regional trade patterns”,The American Eco-nomic Review,85(3),615-623.
34.Melitz,M.J.(2003),“The impact of trade on in-tra-industry reallocations and aggregate industry productivi-ty”,Econometrica,71(6),1695-1725.
35.Nitch,V.(2000),“National borders and interna-tional trade:evidence from the European Union”,The Cana-dian Journal ofEconomics,33(4),1091-1105.
36.Nitch,V.(2001),“It’s not right but it’s okay:on the measurement of intra-and international trade dis-tances”,manuscript,Bankgesellschaft Berlin,Germany.
37.Nitch,V.(2002),“Border effects and border re-gions:lessons from the German Unification”,HWWAdiscus-sion papers,No.203.
38.Obstfeld,M.,and K.S.Rogoff(2000),“The six major puzzles in international macroeconomics:Is there a common cause-”,inNBER Macroeconomics Annual2000,ed.by B.S.Bernanke,and K.S.Rogoff,pp.339-390.The MITPress,U.S.A.
39.Okubo,T.(2004),“The border effects in the Jap-anese market:a gravity model analysis”,Journal ofthe Japa-nese and International Economics,18(1),1-11.
40.Poncet,S.(2003),“Measuring Chinese domestic and international integration”,China Economic Review,14(1),1-21.
41.Poncet,S.(2005),“Afragmented China:measureand determinants of Chinese domestic market disintegration”,ReviewofInternational Economics,13(3),409-430.
42.Roberts,M.J.,and J.R.Tybout(1997),“The decision to export in Colombia:an empirical model of entry with sunk costs”,The American Economic Review,87(4),545-564.
43.Rose,A.K.(2000),“One money,one market:the effect of common currencies on trade”,Economic Policy,15(30),7-46.
44.Rose,A.K.(2001),“Currency union and trade:the effect is large”,Economic Policy,16(33),449-461.
45.Rose,A.K.,and E.van Wincoop(2001),“Na-tional money as a barrier to international trade:the real case for currency union”,The American Economic Review,91(2),386-390.
46.Tingergen,J.(1962),Shaping the world economy:suggestions for an international economic policy.Twentieth Century Fund.,U.S.A.
47.Wei,S.-J.(1996),“Intra-national versus in-ternational trade:How stubborn are nations in global integra-tion-”,NBER working paper,No.5531.
48.Wolf,H.C.(2000),“Intranational home bias in trade”,The ReviewofEconomics and Statistics,82(4),555-563.
49.Yi,K.-M.(2003),“Can vertical specialization explain the growth of world trade-”,The Journal ofPolitical Economy,111(1),52-102.
50.Yi,K.-M.(2008),“Can multi-stage produc-tion explain the home bias in trade-”,Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia working papers,No.08-12.
51.Young,A.(2000),“The razor’s edge:distortions and incremental reform in the People’s Republic of China”,The Quarterly Journal ofEconomics,115(4),1091-1135.
基本信息:
DOI：10.14167/j.zjss.2010.10.020
中图分类号:F014.3
引用信息:
[1]何鸣,柯善咨,王华.引力模型与商品市场分割研究综述[J].浙江社会科学,2010,No.170(10):89-100+128-129.DOI:10.14167/j.zjss.2010.10.020.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金重大项目(07&ZD017)资助
2010-10-15
2010-10-15